Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-7211845-20140607141555/@comment-24785765-20140609132426

Kuby101 wrote: Slideshow engages the user and keeps one preferable frame dimension for all photos.

It does keep one frame size, but it resizes each photo to make it fit within the constraints of the frame. Looking at your examples above (Glacius), I think it looks good for the first few images where they actually fit the slideshow frame, but the last 2 which are a tiled image of the stages of the armor annoy me as they don't fill the frame. In my mind, that is what looks tacky and unprofessional.

KandD GSE Andy wrote:

Well EBCM, if you look at a page like Aegis of Sky Majesty, the pictures are unorganized.

The problem here isn't organization, its bad images, which won't go away with either option, and if thats what we want, then someone needs to be willing to edit out images that are essentially worthless to the wiki.

I still vote option 1 with some stricter guidelines on what photos can be added to each armor page, as both are going to end up with unneeded images that we have to wade through to find what we want.

And if the main goal is display each stage of the armor, as that is all most pages have then we ought to set it up as such. Gallery style, in table format, with no other room for people's random screen shots of themselves.

Male: Stage 1  Stage 2  Stage 3

Female: Stage 1  Stage 2  Stage 3

I get allowing people to contribute their own photos as a community, but maybe there is a better place that this can happen, this would definitely clean up all the unnecessary junk on armor pages that I don't want to see anyway.