Thread:77.4.238.4/@comment-12812688-20131025122936

just because it didn't give the desired results the 1st time, doesn't mean that it does not work. (I test it today 25.10.2013 it doenst work!)

Spectral Captain's Uniform + Forgemaster's Garb - from this combo you could get any 1 to 4 star (other than a few noncraftable legendaries), anything with spirit/earth, spirit/fire, water/earth, water/fire, or any mono-fire or water or earth or spirit

it's just a chance you can get the clayplate mantle. So you not getting it is not a confirmation that it doesn't work. I may just be a lower chance. 