Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-24003134-20140304054224/@comment-24003134-20140306052004

LuxRegem wrote:

JustinDaOne wrote:

Firstly, having a board for guilds will already jeopardize the rule about posting "Friend Codes in other areas than the Share Pages is not acceptable." I don't see this becoming a way to clean the spam away.

Secondly, A guild can have 20+ Members in it, and trust me, They will never stick to creating only 1 Guild Thread because sooner or later their guild thread will be piled up by newer advertisements, so they will create another thread to suffice this. This will require more monitoring for the site, and I am already aware that we are lacking on this matter. I would say the idea is that rule would change to "post your guild only in the forum for it" or something. I think it is a great way to contain guild spamming. People can spam their guild as much as they like in their own thread, and not bother others with it.

A similar system for friend codes would be great too I think.

People will not need to create an extra thread for their guild because they can post additional comments in their original thread. In fact this may lead to some public 'in guild' discussion that may benefit people who want to make an intelligent choice for a guild better than the single share guild post can do now.

A forum like this will reduce the need people feel to post guild spam outside the designated area.

I like the idea. '''"A similar system for friend codes would be great too I think." '''In theory yes, but I don't think it would work well as an entire thread for a few letters with maybe a screenshot probably isn't going to be worth having moderated.

"post your guild only in the forum for it" I was honestly thinking to keep the Share:Guild, but if it sounds like it would be good to remove it that could be a possibility. I think it may be good to keep it though, but that's just my opinion. =]